How Is The Mediator Or Arbitrator Selected?

How Is The Mediator Or Arbitrator Selected?

Real Estate Law: How Is the Mediator or Arbitrator Selected?

In the realm of real estate transactions, disputes can arise between buyers, sellers, landlords, tenants, contractors, and other parties involved in property matters. To resolve these conflicts efficiently and impartially, many parties turn to alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods such as mediation and arbitration. One critical aspect of ADR is the selection of a mediator or arbitrator—the neutral third party who will facilitate the resolution process or issue a binding decision. In this article, we will explore how mediators and arbitrators are selected in real estate disputes, the qualifications and characteristics to consider, the role of parties in the selection process, and the implications of choosing the right neutral.

1. The Role of the Mediator and Arbitrator:


In mediation, the mediator serves as a neutral facilitator who assists the parties in reaching a mutually agreeable resolution. The mediator does not make decisions or impose solutions but instead guides the parties through the negotiation process, helping them explore their interests, communicate effectively, and find common ground. Mediators are trained to remain impartial and focus on the needs and concerns of all parties involved.


In arbitration, the arbitrator plays a more formal role, acting as a decision-maker who hears evidence and arguments presented by the parties and renders a binding decision on the dispute. Arbitrators may be former judges, experienced attorneys, or industry experts with specialized knowledge in real estate matters. While arbitrators are neutral, they have the authority to issue a decision that is legally enforceable and final, subject to limited grounds for appeal.

2. Qualifications and Characteristics of Mediators and Arbitrators:

Neutrality and Impartiality:

One of the essential qualifications for both mediators and arbitrators is neutrality. Neutrality ensures that the neutral third party does not have any conflicts of interest or biases that could influence their decision-making. Parties should look for mediators and arbitrators who are committed to impartially facilitating the resolution process and maintaining fairness throughout.

Expertise in Real Estate Law:

In real estate disputes, it is advantageous to select mediators and arbitrators with expertise in real estate law and industry practices. Understanding the complexities of real estate transactions, contracts, and regulations allows the neutral to effectively navigate the issues at hand and provide valuable insights.

Communication and Negotiation Skills:

Effective communication and negotiation skills are crucial for mediators, as they guide parties through the resolution process. Mediators must create a collaborative atmosphere and encourage open dialogue between disputing parties. Arbitrators should also possess strong communication skills to ensure that all parties’ arguments are heard and understood during the arbitration proceedings.

Experience in ADR:

Experience in alternative dispute resolution is an important factor to consider when selecting a mediator or arbitrator. Experienced neutrals are well-versed in the processes, techniques, and best practices of ADR, enhancing their ability to guide parties toward a satisfactory resolution.

Impartiality and Integrity:

Integrity is a fundamental characteristic of a good mediator or arbitrator. Parties must trust that the neutral will maintain confidentiality, act ethically, and adhere to the established procedures throughout the resolution process.

3. Methods of Selecting a Mediator or Arbitrator:

Agreement Between the Parties:

In some cases, parties involved in a real estate dispute may mutually agree on a specific mediator or arbitrator. This can occur when the parties are familiar with a qualified neutral, have worked with them in the past, or have received recommendations from trusted sources.

Appointing a Neutral from a Respected Institution:

Parties may choose to select a mediator or arbitrator from a respected institution that provides ADR services. Institutions such as the American Arbitration Association (AAA) or JAMS (formerly Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services) have panels of experienced neutrals with expertise in various fields, including real estate.

Court-Appointed Neutrals:

In some instances, a court may appoint a mediator or arbitrator to assist with the resolution of a real estate dispute. Court-appointed neutrals must meet certain qualifications and standards to ensure their competence and impartiality.

Choosing a Neutrals’ Association or Registry:

There are professional organizations and registries that maintain lists of qualified mediators and arbitrators with expertise in various areas of the law, including real estate. Parties can refer to these lists to identify neutrals with suitable qualifications and experience.

4. The Role of Parties in the Selection Process:

Agreement Between Parties:

In mediation, the parties typically agree on the selection of the mediator. This agreement can occur before or after the dispute arises. By involving the parties in the selection process, they have the opportunity to choose a mediator they feel comfortable with, increasing the likelihood of a successful resolution.

Pre-established Agreements:

In some real estate contracts, there may be pre-established provisions that outline the process for selecting a mediator or arbitrator in the event of a dispute. These provisions can simplify the selection process and avoid potential disagreements between the parties.

Balancing Competing Interests:

In arbitration, each party may have preferences regarding the selection of the arbitrator. For example, a party involved in a real estate dispute may prefer an arbitrator with experience in commercial real estate or construction matters. When choosing an arbitrator, parties should aim to balance competing interests and select a neutral who is qualified and impartial.

5. Implications of Selecting the Right Mediator or Arbitrator:

Efficient and Effective Resolution:

Choosing the right mediator or arbitrator can lead to a more efficient and effective resolution process. A qualified and experienced neutral can identify the core issues, navigate complex legal matters, and facilitate productive communication between parties.

Preserving Relationships:

A skilled mediator can help parties find common ground and reach a resolution that preserves relationships. This is particularly valuable in real estate transactions, where parties may have ongoing business interactions.

Legally Binding Decision:

Selecting an experienced arbitrator ensures that the resulting decision is legally binding and enforceable. This provides parties with the certainty of a final resolution without the need for further litigation.

Confidence in the Process:

Parties are more likely to have confidence in the mediation or arbitration process when they trust the selected mediator or arbitrator. Confidence in the process can lead to increased cooperation and a more favorable outcome for all parties involved.

6. Conclusion:

Selecting the right mediator or arbitrator is a crucial step in alternative dispute resolution for real estate disputes. Parties should consider factors such as neutrality, expertise in real estate law, communication skills, and experience in ADR when making their selection. The voluntary nature of ADR allows parties to have a say in the selection process, ensuring that they are comfortable with the neutral facilitating or deciding their dispute. The right mediator or arbitrator can lead to an efficient and effective resolution, preserve relationships, and provide parties with a legally binding decision.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. The selection of a mediator or arbitrator may vary based on the specific laws and regulations governing ADR in different jurisdictions. Parties involved in real estate disputes should seek legal counsel for advice specific to their circumstances.

Whether you’re a property owner, investor, or business owner, Real Estate Law Corporation™ is your trusted partner on the path to legal success. Contact us today to embark on a journey of exceptional legal support. Our team of seasoned attorneys brings decades of experience to every case, demonstrating a profound understanding of real estate law, transactions, litigation, business intricacies, and estate planning. With a proven record of success, our portfolio is adorned with numerous landmark cases that stand as a testament to our dedication, expertise, and commitment to achieving favorable outcomes for our clients.